Between Magellan and Legazpi: The Forgotten Gap, the Rise and Fall of the Habsburgs, and Why the Philippines Became More Mexican Than Spanish
By Karl Garcia
Many histories of the Philippines move quickly from the arrival of Ferdinand Magellan in 1521 to the conquest of Miguel López de Legazpi in 1565, as if Spanish rule followed immediately after first contact. In reality, there was a gap of more than forty years between these two events. This period is often overlooked, yet it explains one of the most important facts about Philippine history: the islands did not become a typical Spanish colony governed directly from Europe. Instead, they became part of the Spanish Pacific world, administered through Mexico, influenced by American-born Spaniards, and shaped by global politics in Europe — especially the rise and decline of the Habsburg dynasty that ruled Spain during the early colonial period.
To understand why the Philippines became tied to Mexico, we must look not only at events in Asia, but also at the power struggles in Europe.
Magellan, Charles V, and the Global Ambitions of the Habsburg Empire
When Magellan sailed in 1519, Spain was ruled by Charles V, one of the most powerful monarchs in European history. He belonged to the House of Habsburg, a family that controlled vast territories across Europe and the Americas.
Charles V was not only King of Spain. He was also Holy Roman Emperor and ruler of lands in Germany, Italy, the Netherlands, and Austria. His empire stretched across continents, and his goal was to compete with Portugal for control of global trade.
Magellan’s voyage must be seen in this context. Spain wanted access to the Spice Islands, which Portugal already dominated. The expedition was part of a global rivalry between two European empires, not a plan to colonize the Philippines.
When Magellan reached the islands in 1521, he claimed them for Spain, but the Habsburg Empire had too many wars in Europe to focus on distant territories. After Magellan’s death in the Battle of Mactan, Spain did not immediately return.
The empire’s attention was elsewhere.
The Habsburg Wars and the Delay in Colonizing the Philippines
During the decades after Magellan, the Habsburg rulers were involved in constant conflicts in Europe. They fought wars against France, against Protestant states in Germany, and against the Ottoman Empire. These struggles consumed money, soldiers, and political attention.
At the same time, Spain was building its empire in the Americas. The conquest of Mexico and Peru brought enormous wealth, especially silver. These colonies became far more important to the Spanish crown than distant islands in Asia.
Because of this, the Philippines remained outside direct Spanish control for more than forty years. Spain did not ignore the islands completely, but it lacked the resources to establish a permanent colony while fighting wars in Europe and organizing its American territories.
The delay between Magellan and Legazpi was therefore not an accident. It was the result of global politics.
The Pacific Empire Built from Mexico
By the mid-1500s, the situation changed. Spain had secured control of Mexico, known as New Spain, and had discovered a reliable route across the Pacific. From Mexico, ships could sail west to Asia and return using northern currents.
This made the Philippines valuable as a trading base. The goal was not to conquer a large land empire, but to create a link between China and the Americas.
In 1565, Miguel López de Legazpi sailed from New Spain, not from Spain itself. His expedition included Spaniards born in the Americas, Mexican natives, and other colonial soldiers. From the beginning, the Philippines was governed through Mexico City.
This arrangement became permanent with the Manila–Acapulco Galleon Trade, which connected Manila to Acapulco for more than two centuries. Silver from Mexico paid for Chinese goods, and the Philippines served as the meeting point of Asian and American trade.
Because of this system, the colony developed closer ties to Mexico than to Spain.
The Later Habsburgs and the Limits of Spanish Power
After Charles V, Spain continued to be ruled by the Habsburg dynasty, including Philip II of Spain, under whom the Philippines was formally organized as a colony. Philip II made Manila the capital and strengthened the galleon trade, but his reign was also marked by enormous military expenses.
Spain fought wars in Europe, the Mediterranean, and the Netherlands. The empire remained powerful, but its resources were stretched thin. Because the Philippines produced little gold or silver, it never became a priority compared to Mexico or Peru.
As the Habsburg line continued, Spain gradually weakened. By the late 1600s, the dynasty faced financial problems, military defeats, and internal decline. The death of Charles II of Spain in 1700 ended the Spanish Habsburg line entirely.
This event led to the War of the Spanish Succession, which reshaped the Spanish Empire and brought the Bourbon dynasty to power.
For the Philippines, these changes in Europe meant that the colony remained distant, underfunded, and dependent on Mexico.
Why the Philippines Felt More Mexican Than Spanish
Because the Philippines was colonized during the Habsburg period and administered through New Spain, its development followed a different path from other Asian territories.
- Soldiers often came from Mexico.
- Priests and officials often came from Mexico.
- Trade depended on Mexico.
- Laws were often enforced through Mexico City.
Even everyday culture showed this connection. Foods, words, and customs traveled across the Pacific along with silver and silk. Filipino society absorbed influences from Spain, but also from Latin America and Asia at the same time.
This is why the Philippines cannot be understood simply as a Spanish colony. It was part of a trans-Pacific empire created during the height of Habsburg power and maintained through the American colonies.
Conclusion: Empire, Dynasty, and Distance
The gap between Magellan and Legazpi reflects more than a delay in colonization. It reflects the realities of a global empire ruled by the Habsburgs, whose attention was divided between Europe, the Americas, and the seas.
Spain reached the Philippines during the rise of the Habsburg Empire, colonized it through Mexico at the height of its power, and governed it from afar as the dynasty declined.
Because of this history, the Philippines became something unique:
not fully European, not fully American, not fully Asian —
but a colony shaped by the politics of Europe, the wealth of Mexico, and the trade of the Pacific.
The Society of Honor by Joe America 